Make in India vs Make for India


Group Discussion

Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:

  • Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.
  • Post your answer now.

Pratik Kumar said: (Dec 11, 2019)  
Hello Everyone,

Let me first explain what is it, that I understand by Make in India and Make for India is make in India means that various types of products we have to manufacture, assemble and packing in India only. While make for India means is that let the other countries make those products for India.

I prefer to make in India rather than make for India because in make in India we are getting a lot of opportunities to get employed as well as this will benefit in the growth of our GDP too. Through this initiative by GoI, we will able to perform our skills and can grow some extra skills also. It will help in a very healthy manner to improve our financial condition and help to grow our skills.

Rate this: +0 -0


Zeeshan said: (Dec 10, 2019)  
Thank you, for giving me an opportunity to share my opinion.

I think that made in India is better than made for India because if foreign country's goods were sold in India then they will earn in our country and our country industry will face competition with them and the price of foreign goods are higher then India's because they include transportation charges.

So I think made in India is better than made for India.

Rate this: +0 -0


Angel said: (Nov 18, 2019)  
In my opinion, Make in India is better than made in India as it helps to reduce the price of import things from foreign countries. We invite the other countries to run their industries in our country and we can get these things at a very low price and also people get opportunities for a job. It is a very good attempt for our country.

Thank you.

Rate this: +19 -7


Vishal Singh said: (Oct 29, 2019)  
I would like to say that make in India is better than make for India.

India is a developing country, requires more employment. Hencemore manufacturing units of different countries are required.

The main purpose of this concept to provideemployement to people who are not much educated and not that much skilled.

It will create lot of jobs in next few years and will also help India to don't rely on other countries. Our country will be self dependent.

Due to this more people will engage with technology.

Thank You.

Rate this: +27 -3


Abdul Mateen said: (Oct 20, 2019)  
Hi, according to me, make in India is much better than that of made for India. Make in India is actually a plan taken by the government. It's better to take decision before the problem.

Think of China most of their products are sold hear we even get it as it is the lowest price. Even make for India might be good in a few times as poor can't afford high-cost things and most of making for India is of less cost. Everything is good until it's up to a limit so reduce make for India and increase make in India.

THANK YOU.

Rate this: +10 -7


Meet Charola said: (Oct 17, 2019)  
Make in India is the initiative started by the government on 25th September 2014 to encourage the companies to manufacture their products in India. In simple way, it aims to make India a "MANUFACTURER HUB" at the global level.

And make for India is not so good as you are looking for India as a market. Thats is not good for the Indian economy as well as the goods which are provided by Indian people, which is used as a raw material in the industries.

Consider the scenario if all the countries will start to place their market in India for selling their products than what will be the situation of Indian products? All our home made small businesses will be dead and the other Indian companies will get so much loss.

And as the result of this 5 years period MAKE IN INDIA is a great initiative and helps a lot to boost up the Indian economy and GDP too.

Rate this: +30 -3


Eeshwari Kulkarni said: (Oct 8, 2019)  
Make in India is helpful for Indians economically providing jobs for jobless but make for India technically considers India as a backward and a still developing country meaning India cannot manufacture/produce for itself and needs the help of other countries.

But yes considering the fact that India is a developing country it definitely needs the help of other countries than the countries which has already been developed.

And otherwise also we require the help of other countries to have a friendly and economic relation.

But, definitely make in India helps our country to grow fast and it is economically effective.

Rate this: +32 -8


Bhumika said: (Oct 3, 2019)  
Make in India means the thing made in India and make for India means the thing that is made for India and coming from another country.

Rate this: +14 -29


Aniket said: (Sep 10, 2019)  
After reading all the opinions mentioned above we can say that govt Launched this event with an idea of improving job opportunity for the poor and the middle man, the project was at full swing in its initial stage but at later stage, which is the present time, it has lost its importance as people who joined schemes like skill India are still unemployed and are not able to earn a living.

Hence the government should look for creating job opportunities for them with a decent salary.

Rate this: +22 -11


Heena said: (Sep 5, 2019)  
Hello Everyone,

Here most of the people support for make in India. And I also support them.

I like most make in India because its purpose is to use our own currency in our own country will indirectly increase the GDP. It will provide enough employement.

It will help to increase our Economical conditions. It will stop the mass of people to move abroad for business, they can make their startup in India.

It will make independent India.

Rate this: +53 -8


Vedika Sharma said: (Jul 11, 2019)  
Make in India sounds much better than make for India. India is a developing economy within the past few years employment has increased due to the MAKE IN INDIA incentive taken by the government of India.

The main purpose of this concept was to provide employment to the people who are not much educated or not that much skilled. This process will increase the value of Indian rupee which will be beneficial for the economy.

So, according to me, MAKE IN INDIA is much better than MAKE FOR INDIA!

Rate this: +99 -10


Patel said: (Jul 5, 2019)  
According to me, Make in India is a great initiative by the government it creates lots of jobs in the country in the next few years.

Well, we have seen in the automotive sector lot of companies have come and made their hubs over here that creates lots of employment in our country and also helps in the growth of GDP.

Over the last decades India has done a tremendous job in investing a power sector and especially in generation side because of this investment we have surplus power so in the generation side there is no issue but the issue is in transmission and distribution but that can be also improving day by day because of many private sectors coming into this area.

So, on the government side, there are lots of changes have been made into policy to allowing various private companies to do their business. Hence, the private sector is pretty dynamic and more startup has come in the country so that will definitely increase the economic value chain.

Rate this: +28 -9


Ajay Parmar said: (Jun 25, 2019)  
Well, Make in India sounds better than Make for India. Because India being a developing country requires more employment, hence more manufacturing unit of different companies. As only one company can't provide that, even if it does so, prices of the product will increase and hence number Of company and their manufacturing unit are required.

Make in India will increase export, hence foreign currency. Simultaneously, Make in India for India & the world will be better our country.

Therefore, Make in India for the world.

Rate this: +42 -7


Nagesh Bharat Sontakke said: (Jun 23, 2019)  
Hello everyone, as a topic has been given.

I would like to speak more about make in India, Because it helps our country more independent and no need to rely on other countries. So basically Make in India scheme levied in India by Govt Of India in Sep. 2014.

It's for 25 sectors that help to build the Indian economy. As we know in India youths number is so high. For increasing the skills and employment among the youth make in India is helpful for needy youths. In the pharmaceutical field also help more as We manufacture our own products and can sell to other countries.

Example : Patanjali manufactures More FMCG products that build the Indian economy.

Rate this: +20 -6


Premasai M S said: (Apr 25, 2019)  
Hi friends,

I want to talk about make in INDIA.

When India is in the position of providing jobs for other countries that make in INDIA.

When other country people's are waiting for the release of our product in a there country that is made in INDIA.

Make for India should also be there but as a part of making in INDIA not as that India is a part of other countries business use.

Because we are a developing country.

When India is fully prepared for making in INDIA then India will be the developed country.

Everyone in the future should be proud to say that I AM AN INDIAN.

Rate this: +33 -19


Rahul Devganiya said: (Apr 21, 2019)  
According to my opinion make in India and make for India both campaigns seems like a good fortune for India.

But the major difference will be done by these two campaigns is quite different because make in India will help to improve job security and also will improve entrepreneurship in India. Because of make in India, people's skill will develop and more people engage with technology. While in make for India campaign people doesn't engage in the workforce directly in this campaign.

Rate this: +23 -7


Mouni said: (Apr 18, 2019)  
The Make in India vs Make for India.

Make in India : leads to the employment and development of small scale industries.
As a result the major problem, which is unemployment will be decreased.

Make for India: this to increase in productivity and meet the people requirements.

Rate this: +57 -7


Asif Hashmi said: (Feb 28, 2019)  
Make in India, make for India, the proposition of in means Indian product for means foreign product respectively.

Consideration on this we have to analyze market need, and market needs variety and option, fortunately, India is a big market it needs self-assistance, self-reliance, on macro and micro level. For the equivalent competition in the global village, India should be in share with an international market with balancing international relation. It's up to us we have to give conscience on motherland product since making in India is not the solution we have to encourage and its needs participation in actual we lack in some aspect these can be fixed by connecting of our home product.

Overall, make in India needs behavioural modification that Indian has the capability of behaviour, mastership, science and quality.

Rate this: +34 -15


Sobhangini said: (Feb 15, 2019)  
I would like to say about make in India.

Make in India means the products which are manufactured is produced by our India companies and all employees are Indian no-one else.

(Advantages of make in India).

1. Creates employment opportunities for Indians.
2. Developing the economic growth of our country.
3. Our country will self-dependent.

Thank you.

Rate this: +90 -11


Gulshan said: (Jan 21, 2019)  
1st of all, I would like to explain the make in India and make for India.

Actually, make in India means the products which is manufactured is produced by our Indian companies and all employees are Indian no-one else.

By making in India India gets lots of opportunities to develop our skills our knowledge etc. And reduce unemployment persons which is the biggest problem in our country. So make in India is a good role in the improvement of our country.

Now Talking about make for India. It means the product is made by other countries and seld to our country. As we know our population is quite high so the need is also wide. So as I personally feel that some requirements should be taken from the other countries and learn from them how they are designing.

After taking a lot of space I just want to conclude my point by saying that the make in India and make for India both are required to fulfil our needs but the make for India should be the part of make in India.

Rate this: +203 -26


Naveena D said: (Jan 1, 2019)  
Good Morning Friends,

First of all, By using make in India we can develop our country and also provide good employment services to the people. It will helpful for our young generation for developing the country. So it will be automatically develop make for India.

Rate this: +47 -10


Shashi said: (Dec 21, 2018)  
Good morning everyone.

First of all, I will clear the difference between make in India and made in India.

Make in India is an initiative taken by the government of India for the purpose of promoting our made products. For the purpose of developing of economic growth and show that our country is not dependent to another country. In make in India, our country invites to foreign companies to produce our goods and services in India which is beneficial to our country.

In make for India is that in which the foreign companies produced our product in our country and then sell it to our country. Which is not good for our country.

Advantages of making in India.

1 creates employment opportunities.
2. Developing economic growth of our country.
3. Self-dependent.

Disadvantages of Make for India.

1. Companies earn money and go back to our country which reflects economic growth.
2. Dependent on another country.

Example of make in India.

Patanjali has produced all FMCG products in our country to increase our economic growth.

Thank you.

Rate this: +52 -28


Vishal said: (Oct 14, 2018)  
Good morning everyone.

First of all, I will clear the difference between make in India and made in India.

Make in India is an initiative taken by the government of India for the purpose of promoting our made products. For the purpose of developing of economic growth and show that our country is not dependent to another country. In make in India, our country invites to foreign companies to produce our goods and services in India which is beneficial to our country.

In make for India is that in which the foreign companies produced our product in our country and then sell it to our country. Which is not good for our country.

Advantages of making in India.

1 creates employment opportunities.
2. Developing economic growth of our country.
3. Self-dependent.

Disadvantages of Make for India.

1. Companies earn money and go back to our country which reflects economic growth.
2. Dependent on another country.

Example of make in India.

Patanjali has produced all FMCG products in our country to increase our economic growth.

Thank you.

Rate this: +80 -33


Ravindra said: (Oct 10, 2018)  
Hello everyone!

Today's topic is" MAKE IN INDIA vs MAKE FOR INDIA" right?

So firstly I want to give brief I want to give a brief introduction about both. "MAKE IN INDIA" means companies will make their products in India and they will sell their product in India whether "MAKE FOR INDIA" means the foreign countries will make their products for INDIA and they will sell in India.

I totally agree with "MAKE IN INDIA" project which was given by our Prime Minister 'NARENDRA MODI' in September 2014. He saw that lots of people those who are living in India they are mostly using foreign brands and products more than the Indian brands and products and they are paying lots of money for foreign products. They are continuously increasing the economic growth of the foreign countries that's why foreign countries are moving towards growth continuously. This is 'MAKE FOR INDIA' they are making products for India and Indians are using their products more than Indian products.

The Question is that why they are using foreign products and brands more than the Indians Products and brands that's because of there no availability of such kinds of products and brands. By seeing that our Prime Minister 'Narendra Modi' launch "MAKE IN INDIA' project under which the people will become able to use Indian brands and products rather than foreign products with very less price and if they will pay money for their products in India so economic growth of India will increase and our country will automatically move towards the developments.

There are some advantages and disadvantages of MAKE IN INDIA projects.

The advantages are:

The students who go abroad to for their higher and better studies and for that they are paying lots of money to the foreign counties education system. So if there will availabilities of such kind of education then why they will go abroad they will start studying in India and they will pay money for Indian education systems and day by day the Indian education systems become strong.

Under MAKE IN INDIA projects our PM also said that they want to make 100 smarts cities, it will be very fruitful for youngster's they JOB opportunities will increase for them and they will be able to live their better life.

Disadvantages are:

Land degradation will increase because there will be more requirements for lands to make 100 smarts Cities And lots of Industries, Agriculture activities will decrease.

Deforestation will increase.

Pollution will increase automatically due to deforestation and Industries.

Thank You.

Rate this: +193 -19


Lavanya Dandu said: (Oct 8, 2018)  
Yes both should have balance to develop the country. Mostly make in India is going to hep us in development of the country.

Rate this: +20 -26


Deepak Makode said: (Sep 25, 2018)  
I'll definitely support the make in India scheme as it has made our country self-dependent instead of relying on others.

In My point of view, that Make in India is more important then Make for India at present, Make in India is a type of Swadesh movement covering 25 sectors of the economy and it was launched by our Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi to encourage the company to manufacture their product within India and also to increase their investment.

The main objective for having made in India is that there is a job creation and the skill enhancement and large impact on the economy of our country.

Make in India scheme as it is rather a new scheme as compared to the Make for India.

The policy of 'make in India' is simply a replication of the Chinese policy.

Make in India may be an ideal strategy for India's growth. The 'make in India' policy might be a smart move towards making India a developed nation in every field of development. Every policy designed towards the betterment of the nation should also include areas of benefit for the common people of the country. A balanced mix of 'make in India' and 'make for India' would be ideal for a developing nation as ours.

Rate this: +51 -12


Abhigyan Nandan said: (Sep 16, 2018)  
In my opinion, both Make in India and Make for India schemes have a large impact on the economy of our country. But we should prioritize on the Make in India scheme as it is rather a new scheme as compared to the Make for India scheme since the latter is going on for quite a long time.

Time and again, it has been proved that India has the talent in developing into one of the leading superpowers in the world. Every year ten of thousands of engineers, doctors, researchers are produced by our countries. But only a few percent among them get work for the leading companies in India based on their merits. We have an abundance of resources to further the Make for India scheme. But they are being wasted in developing products outside the country rather than within. The Make for India scheme is one of the revolutionizing decisions taken by our Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Along with the Make in India scheme, we must equally focus on Make for India which is source for ideas for the youth of our country. By getting a taste of technologies of other countries, we would continue to rise to the challenge of improving and developing technologies to make our country India as one of the focus points in the economy and markets all around the world.

Rate this: +25 -6


Rahul Kumar said: (Sep 3, 2018)  
In My point of view, that Make in India is more important then Make for India at present, but there should be a proper balance between the both to achieve the maximum efficiency.

Make in India is a type of Swadesh movement covering 25 sectors of the economy and it was launched by our Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi to encourage the company to manufacture their product within India and also to increase their investment.

The main objective for having make in India is that there is a job creation and the skill enhancement and also to transform India into a global design and manufacturing hub by increasing importing that exporting, I think that Make in India should be an urgently put in effect as we are lagging behind in creating our own Technology. Also, the government should show some sort of support to our new entrepreneur or the multi-national companies for adopting this idea. PM Narendra Modi also coined the slogan Zero Defect Zero Effect which means that the product manufactured or produced in India is with no defect and no ecological effect.

But at the same time make for India is also important to balance so that we can learn from the other country how they are self-dependent on themselves also if the need arises they are aspiring to develop the product in their own country. As we are the developer and we learn many things by depending on them, So we cannot completely abolish the Make for India schemes.

Rate this: +78 -11


Himanshu said: (Aug 30, 2018)  
Before starting let's have a glance on the difference between make in India and make for India.

Make in India scheme refers to carrying out the production part in India rather being dependent on other countries while making for India focuses on just the opposite that is getting the things manufactured by other countries for India.

I'll definitely support the make in India scheme as it has made our country self-dependent instead of relying on others. Inviting the various companies to invest in India, It has played a great role in benefiting our country's economy in an overwhelming manner. The make in India scheme must be further promoted as it will help in creating more job opportunities in our country as a large section of our people is still unemployed. Along with this, there will be more export business as compared to the import part thus helping in uplifting the Indian economy.

But at the same time, to compete with the current technology trends we cannot completely abolish the make for India scheme. Thus, it's just a matter of prioritizing both the schemes in a balanced manner so as to achieve maximum efficiency.

Rate this: +38 -5


Jane said: (Aug 29, 2018)  
Make in India is definitely the better initiative for our country. By importing stuff from other countries we are just making them richer and improving their economy, rather via this scheme we actually have a chance to contribute to our country's economy. Whereas make for India just promotes importing all over again and that just contradicts the point that we are proving with make in India initiative.

Rate this: +13 -5


Jane said: (Aug 29, 2018)  
Make in India is definitely the better initiative for our country. By importing stuff from other countries we are just making them richer and improving their economy, rather via this scheme we actually have a chance to contribute to our country's economy. Whereas make for India just promotes importing all over again and that just contradicts the point that we are proving with made in India initiative.

Rate this: +5 -3


Ashok Kumar said: (Aug 14, 2018)  
Make in India is really a great scheme because by this scheme, more youth will get job and if Indian participates in job then they will learn about new technology and our country will develop more faster.

In the other hand, Make for India shows that we are dependent on other country. Also, make for India doesn't help to improve Indian economy.

Rate this: +28 -10


Visha said: (Aug 14, 2018)  
Hello everyone.

First of all, what is the difference between making in India and make for India.

So make in India is the initiative taken by the government in which it encourages to other countries to come in India and make their products in India.

And make for India is we are depending on other countries to make a product for our India.

So these are the basic difference between these. The make in India is a good initiative taken by the government because now we can compare our India with other countries.

Earlier doing business in India was quite difficult but after the launched of made in India, it becomes easier to start a business in India. So according to make in India is much good as compare to make for India.

Thank you.

Rate this: +38 -9


Nskr said: (Aug 11, 2018)  
I would like to add a few points about make in India.

Make in India plan proposed by the government mainly to improve our economy and trying to keep India in the first position in every field.

We all know that India is 1st in space research development and we are very proud to say that.

A part of the implementation of this plan the government should give permissions to some startups which definitely improve our economy.

The main intention of the government is to make our India "ZERO DEFECTS AND ZERO EFFECTS" through making in India policy.

Rate this: +18 -8


Payal said: (Aug 9, 2018)  
Make in India is a campaign started by the central government to develop Indian economy by making it independent and reduce imports. To boost this campaign, government has increased import duties, increased FDI in retail business to 100%, eased the terms of doing business in India.

Rate this: +16 -4


Xcif said: (Aug 5, 2018)  
We need scheme like Make in India urgently as we are lagging behind in creating our own technology and have got bad habit of depending on others, As a result we always have to look on others, Today if we are dreaming of becoming a superpower then we have to see the present examples set by the existing superpowers that they are self-dependent on many things and always aspiring to attain new.

So, we need to Make in India scheme as our country doesn't lack the skill to acquire that but some sort of support from the government,

But we cannot diminish the important role of Make for India as to get an idea of some new technology because getting an idea of others knowledge is also a part of learning ex-China and helps to develop ours and one more thing is to have good relations with other countries, trade between them is the key.

So, I think we need to maintain a balance between Make in India and Make for India, Definitely Make in India should have upper hand.

Rate this: +41 -5


Make in India vs Make for India

Name *:

Email   : (optional)

» Your comments will be displayed only after manual approval.