How effective are Indian B-schools?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
81 comments Page 2 of 9.
Maks said:
1 decade ago
Business schools are now a days becoming placement agencies and students also started judging B-schools on the basis of their placements not on the basis of curriculum and faculties, rather than concentrating on studies students concentrates only for placements because of this mindset sometimes they will not be good at concepts also and which will lead them no where.
(4)
Pratibha said:
1 decade ago
My opinion for B-schools in India is that it is simply becoming a business these days. The way the institutes make calls to all students is simply marketing. Instead of imparting proper education,knowledge and different skills required for managers they are simply attracting students by placements.
(29)
Ankita said:
1 decade ago
Business schools are now a days becoming placement agencies and students also started judging B-schools on the basis of their placements not on the basis of curriculum and faculties, rather than concentrating on studies students concentrates only for placements because of this mindset sometimes they will not be good at concepts also and which will lead them no where.
(11)
Nayeem said:
1 decade ago
I completely agree with the point that B-School has became a shortcut to get placed with hunky salary. I also agree with the point says B-School are running it as a business to fill their own pockets on the name of placement. But I want to ask a question that.. Will you join an institute that provides 100% placement or an institute with no placement ? Just ask this question to yourself.. Will you join ? You will not because you too want to earn a good salary soon after completion of MBA and whats wrong in that if you are getting assistance from experts who promote you to build your career.
Now coming to the quality of education that B-School is providing to their candidates. There isn't any organization left which teaches.. not even IIMs or IITs. They will just guide you. One more point with regard to MBA, no body can teach you Business Management. It need to be touched and felt. I am very much sure that a young man who just know English and has worked under his father in a organized shop can understand Business Administration (if study), better than a candidate who has come blindly by just cracking hefty entrance Exam. Now a days no college in India teaches engineering or business management, its you who should carry the entire course on your own shoulder. So where it matters, its matters in placement as well as the college tag.
Now coming to the quality of education that B-School is providing to their candidates. There isn't any organization left which teaches.. not even IIMs or IITs. They will just guide you. One more point with regard to MBA, no body can teach you Business Management. It need to be touched and felt. I am very much sure that a young man who just know English and has worked under his father in a organized shop can understand Business Administration (if study), better than a candidate who has come blindly by just cracking hefty entrance Exam. Now a days no college in India teaches engineering or business management, its you who should carry the entire course on your own shoulder. So where it matters, its matters in placement as well as the college tag.
(110)
Soumya solution said:
1 decade ago
B-school are becoming a great business days because their main motive is to attract the student's main weakness i.e. job. So they attract student by giving the placement, hence all students are getting attracted upon them. So judge by yourself how effective is it?
(6)
Bindiya said:
1 decade ago
Hi friends,
B-schools in India have become an attractive and easy business in today's scenario. More and more institutes are mushrooming and students are attracted towards them by their placement ads and prestigious MBA tag. But still the real standard of study is maintained by some of the institutes only. The students of most general B-schools are seen as salesmen in their training or as agents of various finance companies. The increased number of schools and passed out students has reduced the value of a MBA degree. Students pay huge amounts of money to get into these schools but may or may not get jobs as expected.
So B-schools in India need to raise their standards to produce efficient and competent world class managers.
B-schools in India have become an attractive and easy business in today's scenario. More and more institutes are mushrooming and students are attracted towards them by their placement ads and prestigious MBA tag. But still the real standard of study is maintained by some of the institutes only. The students of most general B-schools are seen as salesmen in their training or as agents of various finance companies. The increased number of schools and passed out students has reduced the value of a MBA degree. Students pay huge amounts of money to get into these schools but may or may not get jobs as expected.
So B-schools in India need to raise their standards to produce efficient and competent world class managers.
(33)
Padma said:
1 decade ago
Yes, business schools have a major role to develop the country. But they are try to develop them only, not develop the who are entering in to that schools. They just give the degree, but not giving the knowledge. So, there is need to develop the standards of that education system in business schools.
(9)
Ritu pant said:
1 decade ago
B- schools in India are just like business these day. There many so called MBA colleges opened in every street in the city of India and it is very difficult to differentiate between colleges which are good or best. So because of that any one can do MBA from any college by giving a high amount of fees. But the education system in these b- schools is not so effective, so less companies comes to recruit students from these colleges. That's why these students have degree but no jobs. And it lead to unemployment.
(52)
Shilpa said:
1 decade ago
According to my opinion these B schools are the main reasons of why students rare not ready to do hard work because they have an alternative so instead of focussing on study they are focussing on jobs.
(6)
TAHIR said:
1 decade ago
I am not opposing any body with there own views, I agree with other's point that B school gives platform to learn leadership skill, case studies, provide's practical knowledge but I have some question *why they giving fake information related placements (giving lots of companies name in their blog).
Why govt is giving permission & AICTE UGC giving affiliation to such colleges?
Why there is no restriction's ?
This is competitive era everybody want to take higher higher qualification.
If this B Schools attract students like this than they are not going to suffer but we are going to face problem & even country will face unemployment problem more and more.
SO my point is there should some restriction for B SCHOOLS.
Why govt is giving permission & AICTE UGC giving affiliation to such colleges?
Why there is no restriction's ?
This is competitive era everybody want to take higher higher qualification.
If this B Schools attract students like this than they are not going to suffer but we are going to face problem & even country will face unemployment problem more and more.
SO my point is there should some restriction for B SCHOOLS.
(49)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers