General Knowledge - Indian Politics - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Indian Politics - Indian Politics (Q.No. 60)
60.

The Nagaland State of India cannot be termed as a state because it lacks

sovereignty
bicameral legislature
a high court exclusively of its own
None of the above
Answer: Option
Explanation:
No answer description is available. Let's discuss.
Discussion:
24 comments Page 1 of 3.

Heena said:   7 years ago
In political science, we studied that state is actually a country and J&K, Karnataka etc are federations units state and country are used synonymously. There might be possible that state is used as a country.

Mihir kumar said:   8 years ago
1- According to Jean Bodin, "Sovereignty as the absolute and perpetual power of commanding in a state, as the 'supreme power over citizens and subjects unrestrained by law.

2- Sovereignty arms the state both internal and external spheres.

3- Internally it establishes supremacy of all state over all individuals and associations as well as the territory under its control.
3a- Externally it upholds the independence of the state from the control or interference of any other state or any other agency in the conduct of its international relation.

4-So now it is clear that Nagaland has a lack of sovereignty because it is not an independent state, it belongs to India so it was controlled by India. Internally India establishes supremacy over Nagaland and overall its individual and association.

5-Externally, it was controlled by India. Thus, Nagaland has a lack of sovereignty on account of it is internally and externally in the domination of India.

Arafath said:   8 years ago
Thanks @Umer.

Umer said:   9 years ago
Actually, here we talk about a state as a political term, in which all the four elements i,e population, territory, government, & sovereignty (internal plus external).

Nagaland is a state as the other 29 states of India, but it lakes external sovereignty so it's not a state in political terms. Hope this is the answer of the question.
(2)

Amina said:   9 years ago
Nagaland is purely a 16th state of India.

Kumar said:   9 years ago
Nagaland is a state. Not a country.

Shahkai said:   9 years ago
Everyone don't be confused. Refer to @Pradeep Choubey comment.

Rupak said:   9 years ago
Why the Nagaland cannot be termed as a state? Then India has 29 - 1 = 28 states only.

Sameer said:   1 decade ago
Yes Jammu and Kashmir is a sovereign state due to its special status via Art. 370.

Sole said:   1 decade ago
Nagaland attained statehood in dec 1, 1963 inaugurated by the then India president, S. Radhakrishnan and now after 50 years of statehood why the question arising that it cannot be termed as state?


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.