Chemical Engineering - Heat Transfer - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Heat Transfer - Section 1 (Q.No. 19)
19.
For shell and tube heat exchanger, with increasing heat transfer area, the purchased cost per unit heat transfer area
increases
decreases
remains constant
passes through a maxima
Answer: Option
Explanation:
No answer description is available. Let's discuss.
Discussion:
17 comments Page 1 of 2.

Deepak said:   3 weeks ago
Why cost per unit area decreases with increasing area?

This is due to economies of scale in heat exchanger manufacturing. The purchased cost of a shell-and-tube heat exchanger does not increase linearly with area; instead, it follows a power-law relationship:

Typically, for shell-and-tube exchangers, the exponent is approximately $n approximately 0.6$ .

Cost per unit area:
Since $n-1$ is negative, the cost per unit area decreases as area $A$ increases .

Practical reason:

Fixed costs (design, fabrication setup, shells, heads) are spread over more surface area
Larger exchangers use material more efficiently (less material per unit area)
Manufacturing and installation costs don't scale linearly.

So, the correct Answer is : Option B — decreases.

Mongam Damodhar Rao said:   2 years ago
What does it mean to pass through maxima?

Please explain.

Nikhil Verma IITM said:   2 years ago
This is because the fixed costs of the equipment (such as the cost of the shell, tube sheets, and other components) are spread over a larger surface area, leading to economies of scale.

Amjed Qarahgouli said:   4 years ago
In my opinion, the increase of the heat transfer area may be a high cost.

Avinash Kumar Singh said:   6 years ago
It is about the insulation done on the bodies, as a graph of " heat loss vs radius of insulation".
(1)

Nilesh said:   6 years ago
Please give explanation for this question.

Himanshu said:   7 years ago
Please give valid explanation.

Akash Jacob Thankachan said:   7 years ago
Please give the clear explanation.

Jilesh Pandya said:   8 years ago
How this can happen? Kindly give the detailed explanation.
(1)

Prathyu said:   9 years ago
Give explanation for the answer.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.