Aptitude - Problems on Trains - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Problems on Trains - General Questions (Q.No. 28)
28.
A train overtakes two persons walking along a railway track. The first one walks at 4.5 km/hr. The other one walks at 5.4 km/hr. The train needs 8.4 and 8.5 seconds respectively to overtake them. What is the speed of the train if both the persons are walking in the same direction as the train?
66 km/hr
72 km/hr
78 km/hr
81 km/hr
Answer: Option
Explanation:

4.5 km/hr = ( 4.5 x 5 ( m/sec = 5 m/sec = 1.25 m/sec, and
18 4

5.4 km/hr = ( 5.4 x 5 ( m/sec = 3 m/sec = 1.5 m/sec.
18 2

Let the speed of the train be x m/sec.

Then, (x - 1.25) x 8.4 = (x - 1.5) x 8.5

=> 8.4x - 10.5 = 8.5x - 12.75

=> 0.1x = 2.25

=> x = 22.5

Therefore Speed of the train = ( 22.5 x 18 ( km/hr = 81 km/hr.
5

Discussion:
54 comments Page 1 of 6.

Chanda said:   1 decade ago
Please some one explain me in detail. Thank you

Nitesh Nandwana said:   1 decade ago
Hi Chanda,

If two trains (or bodies) start at the same time from points A and B towards each other and after crossing they take a and b sec in reaching B and A respectively, then:

(A's speed) : (B's speed) = (b : a)

Deepika said:   1 decade ago
Please explain me only the last step.

Gowthami said:   1 decade ago
Hi Deepika

The last step is converting m/sec to km/hr.

But i am not understanding how can the dist be equated?
(x - 1.25) x 8.4 = (x - 1.5) x 8.5
can any one explain it plz.

Gowthami said:   1 decade ago
@Gowthami

4.5km/hr=4.5x5m/sec =5m/sec=1.25m/sec
5.4km/hr=5.4x5m/sec=3m/sec=1.5m/sec
then speed of the train=x
distance=speed*time
so distance=(x-1.25)*8.4-------------1
distance=(x-1.5)*8.5----------------2
(1)=(2)
(x - 1.25) x 8.4 = (x - 1.5) x 8.5

Manasa said:   1 decade ago
There is no need of confusion regarding this problem.
in this problem...train and the two persons are moving in the same direction...

Consider the speed of the train be X km/hr.
**(note:the SPEED and LENGTH remains same in both the cases)****
----------------------------------------------------------------
now let us consider relative speed of the train w.r.to the first person..we get...(X-1.25)
in similar manner,relative speed w.r.to the second train...we get...(X-1.5)
(NOTE:why i'm doing subtraction here ,since they are moving in the same direction)

now we know,distance=speed*time
(x - 1.25) x 8.4 = (x - 1.5) x 8.5
8.4x - 10.5 = 8.5x - 12.75
0.1x = 2.25
x = 22.5
speed of the train=22.5 * (5/18)=81km/hr

Swetha said:   1 decade ago
Good explanation. Thank you manasa.

Vinay said:   1 decade ago
But as manasa said why to equal both the relative speed's.

I am not understanding. Can any one please help me.

Gururaj said:   1 decade ago
But the two man is also moving then there is change in distance, so how then (x-1.25)x8.4=(x-1.5)x8.5 both are moving so both the distance are varying.

Can some one please explain this?

Vinay rawat said:   1 decade ago
How can we assume that the distance is equal ?


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.