Aptitude - Problems on Trains - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Problems on Trains - General Questions (Q.No. 4)
4.
Two trains running in opposite directions cross a man standing on the platform in 27 seconds and 17 seconds respectively and they cross each other in 23 seconds. The ratio of their speeds is:
1 : 3
3 : 2
3 : 4
None of these
Answer: Option
Explanation:

Let the speeds of the two trains be x m/sec and y m/sec respectively.

Then, length of the first train = 27x metres,

and length of the second train = 17y metres.

27x + 17y = 23
x+ y

27x + 17y = 23x + 23y

4x = 6y

x = 3 .
y 2

Discussion:
233 comments Page 16 of 24.

Carlo said:   1 decade ago
Let Train A distance = 27x Train A speed = x.

Train B distance = 17y Train B speed = y.

Time = distance/speed.

23 = 27x + 17y / x + y.

x/y = 3/2 ----> Answer.

Vipul said:   1 decade ago
First we are doing KM Hr to MS.
Then Formula is a*5/18.

Then,
45*5/18=75/6 MS.

Distance = Speed*Time.
= 75/6*30.
= 375.

Distance = 375-130.
= 245.

Dileep kumar said:   1 decade ago
27x + 17y/(x+y) = 23;

27x + 17y = 23x + 23y;

4x = 5y;

x/y = 5/4.

Harry Joshi said:   1 decade ago
@Hardik Mistry : When trains move in opposite direction their speeds are added, but when they go in the same direction their speeds are subtracted. Imagine you are going on road by bike and another bike is coming from front (i. e opposite direction) , you feel that the other bike is coming faster. But if it comes from back and tries to overtake you (i.e same direction) then it overtakes you slowly as compared to its speed.

Hardik Mistry said:   1 decade ago
@Faty how can you say total speed is (x+y). Duh the train are moving in different direction. So their total speed need to be (x-y) according to your point of view.

Fatty said:   1 decade ago
Hai every body,
The speed of one train = x, Speed of another train = y.
We know that speed = length/time || length = speed*time.

So we find the length of the first train = x(speed)*27(time).

The length of the second train = y(speed)*17(time).

Time taken by both train to cross(total time) = 23.

Total length = (length of the first train)+(length of the second train) = (x*27)+(y*17).

Total speed = (speed of first train) + (speed of the second train) = x+y.
Total time = total length/total speed.

23 = [(x*27)+(y*17)]/(x+y).
27x+17y = 23(x+y).
27x+17y = 23x+23y ||27x-23x = 23y-17y || 4x = 6y ||x/y = 3/2.

Shekharsa said:   1 decade ago
When two train s of a length a and b, of speed u, v m/sec.they move to cross each other. Time taken by the two trains cross each other is a+b(u+v). Because of these formula we have find the length of trains. I hope understood these problem.

Krishna Chavan said:   1 decade ago
Given data:

l1=27 m/s.
l2=17m/s.

Now, we can find speed
s=l/t .

But speed is not given consider speeds x and y.

Now easy to find lengths,
l1=t*s =27x
l2=t*s =17y

If two trains travelling in opposite directions then we add two lengths(l1 and l2) and x and y speed m/s so that we able to find ratios.

Now the time taken by train to cross each other is given i.e 23 seconds.

Now formula forms like this :

( l1 + l2)
---------- = 23.
( x + y )

( 27x + 17 y)=( 23x + 23y ).

(27x - 23x ) = ( 23y - 17y ).

(4x)=(6y).

x 6 3
-=-=-
y 4 2

Gulshan said:   1 decade ago
Here concept of relative velocity is used.

When objects move opposite to each other, their speed is added and when they move in same direction speed is the difference of their respective speeds.

Shoeb said:   1 decade ago
If 2 Train are moving in opposite direction(train a 27 & train b 17)then Formula applied is

The time taken by the trains to cross each other( 23 )given =(a + b)/(u + v)sec.

* 27u + 17v = 23
-----------
u + v

* 27u + 17v = 23u + 23v

* 27u - 23u = 23v - 17v

* 4u = 6v

* u/v = 6/4

* 3:2 is the answer.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.