Verbal Reasoning - Blood Relation Test - Discussion
Discussion Forum : Blood Relation Test - Blood Relation 1 (Q.No. 5)
5.
Introducing a boy, a girl said, "He is the son of the daughter of the father of my uncle." How is the boy related to the girl?
Answer: Option
Explanation:
The father of the boy's uncle → the grandfather of the boy and daughter of the grandfather → sister of father.
Discussion:
90 comments Page 9 of 9.
Ramkumar said:
1 decade ago
The answer is correct,
My uncle (my Mother's brother)father - Grand father.
Daughter of grand father is girl's mother,
Son of daughter(girl's mother's son) - Answer is brother.
My uncle (my Mother's brother)father - Grand father.
Daughter of grand father is girl's mother,
Son of daughter(girl's mother's son) - Answer is brother.
(1)
Kapil Datta said:
1 decade ago
The answer is either cousin or brother. Such dubiousness should be avoided while framing questions. Using the elimination process does not test any kind of logical reasoning skills in you, in fact it is an incorrect assumption on part of the content developer. Guys, since when have we started looking for the most logical answer amongst incorrect choices.
Ajay Singh said:
1 decade ago
Question Says:
Uncle = Father's Brother.
Father of my Uncle= Grandfather of Boy---(1).
And son of the daughter of Grand Father Means she is the sister of Boys Father.
Both are Brothers.
Uncle = Father's Brother.
Father of my Uncle= Grandfather of Boy---(1).
And son of the daughter of Grand Father Means she is the sister of Boys Father.
Both are Brothers.
Rajkumar said:
1 decade ago
I got the answer without see the explanation when I saw this explanation I fully confused.
Balakumar C said:
1 decade ago
@Sundar. Good explanation. But there needs to be two corrections.
1. Your answer will be perfect when its given that "He is the son of the ""only"" daughter of the father of my uncle. ".
2. In Intro given by India bix, if its given simply as uncle, one has to take it as father's bro. One have to take it as mother's bro only when its given as maternal uncle. This is pointed by Sandeep.
1. Your answer will be perfect when its given that "He is the son of the ""only"" daughter of the father of my uncle. ".
2. In Intro given by India bix, if its given simply as uncle, one has to take it as father's bro. One have to take it as mother's bro only when its given as maternal uncle. This is pointed by Sandeep.
Anshu said:
1 decade ago
Nice explaination sundar.
Jitendra behera said:
1 decade ago
According to me the answer is right.
Preethi said:
1 decade ago
Hey its confusing guys. How?
(1)
Sandeep said:
1 decade ago
As per case 1 of Sundar, brother of girls mother is maternal uncle but not uncle.
In the question they given uncle but not maternal uncle.
So uncle is fathers brother.
In that case ans is cousin but not brother.
In the question they given uncle but not maternal uncle.
So uncle is fathers brother.
In that case ans is cousin but not brother.
Sundar said:
1 decade ago
@All
Please read my explanation given below carefully.
[ Remember: Cousin = The child of one's aunt or uncle. ]
Case-1:
If {the Girl's uncle = Brother of Girl's Mother}
Then the answer will be 'Brother or Cousin'.
Case-2:
If {the Girls uncle = Brother of Girl's Father}
Then the answer will be 'Cousin'.
Among the given options, there is no option for 'Cousin'.
So, we have to choose 'Brother' as the correct answer.
Tips: Use elimination method, just ignore the options that are not suitable. Then the remaining one is 'Brother'.
Note: In what situation will the answer be Brother?
If {the Girl's uncle = Brother of Girl's Mother}
Then, the Father of Girl's Uncle = Girl's Grand_Father(G_F)
In case, G_F's daughter =(might-be)= Girl's mother.
In this situation only, the boy will be Brother to that Girl. Otherwise, the answer will be cousin.
Hope this will help you a bit. Have a nice day!
Please read my explanation given below carefully.
[ Remember: Cousin = The child of one's aunt or uncle. ]
Case-1:
If {the Girl's uncle = Brother of Girl's Mother}
Then the answer will be 'Brother or Cousin'.
Case-2:
If {the Girls uncle = Brother of Girl's Father}
Then the answer will be 'Cousin'.
Among the given options, there is no option for 'Cousin'.
So, we have to choose 'Brother' as the correct answer.
Tips: Use elimination method, just ignore the options that are not suitable. Then the remaining one is 'Brother'.
Note: In what situation will the answer be Brother?
If {the Girl's uncle = Brother of Girl's Mother}
Then, the Father of Girl's Uncle = Girl's Grand_Father(G_F)
In case, G_F's daughter =(might-be)= Girl's mother.
In this situation only, the boy will be Brother to that Girl. Otherwise, the answer will be cousin.
Hope this will help you a bit. Have a nice day!
(2)
Post your comments here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers