Aptitude - Time and Work - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Time and Work - General Questions (Q.No. 7)
7.
A can do a piece of work in 4 hours; B and C together can do it in 3 hours, while A and C together can do it in 2 hours. How long will B alone take to do it?
8 hours
10 hours
12 hours
24 hours
Answer: Option
Explanation:

A's 1 hour's work = 1 ;
4

(B + C)'s 1 hour's work = 1 ;
3

(A + C)'s 1 hour's work = 1 .
2

(A + B + C)'s 1 hour's work = ( 1 + 1 ) = 7 .
4 3 12

B's 1 hour's work = ( 7 - 1 ) = 1 .
12 2 12

Therefore B alone will take 12 hours to do the work.

Discussion:
98 comments Page 8 of 10.

Ashish said:   1 decade ago
Good question. Reasoning is difficult for this one.

Nagendramurthy said:   1 decade ago
Hi friends,

(A+C-A)=C
(1/2-1/4)=1/4

so C's 1 hour work will be 1/4.

Similarly

(B+C-C)=B
(1/3-1/4)=1/12

Therefore B's 1 hour work is 1/12.

Nagarjun said:   1 decade ago
A's 1 hour work is 1/4
(A+C)'s 1 hour work is 1/2
(B+C)'s 1 hour work is 1/3
so, A+C=1/2 ->X and B+C=1/3 ->Y
subtract X-Y
we will get A-B=1/6
now, substitute A's value in d equation u vl get B's value as 1/12.
which is 1 day,s work of B...
hence B alone require 12 days...

I HOPE IT VL B HELPFULL...

Varseyny said:   2 decades ago
A=1/4 (given)
(B+C)=1/3 (given)
(A+B+C)=(1/4+1/3) then take L.C.M
3+4/12=7/12
FIND FOR B
A+B+C=7/12
B=7/12-(A+C) given(A+C=1/2)
B=7/12-(1/2)=1/12
ANS:12

Saleem said:   1 decade ago
Hi.

A = 1/4....(1).
B+C = 1/3....(2).
A+C = 1/2....(3).

Now solve equation (1) & (3).

1/4+C = 1/2.
C = 1/4....(4).

Put C value in equation (2).

B+1/4 = 1/3.
B = 1/3-1/4.

B = 1/12 that's the answer.

Akhil said:   10 years ago
A = 4 (ie A completes the work in 4 hours)
B + C in 3.
A + C in 2.

By taking LCM 4, 3, 2 = Total work or LCM is 12hrs work.

A 1-hour work is 3/ 3*4 = 12 (ie takes 4 hours to complete total work 12 hours already given in question follow same with B + C and A + C).

B + C 1 hour work is 4/4*3 = 12.
A + C 1 hour work is 6/6*2 = 12.

A = 3
B + C = 4
A + C = 6

3A + 3C
1B + 3C

A = 3
B = 1
C = 3
So, B takes 1hr x12 = 12 hour to complete the work.

Haripriya said:   10 years ago
a = 1/4;
b+c = 1/3;
a+c = 1/2.

Therefore find the c value first:- a+c = 1/2.

1/4+c = 1/2.
c = 1/4.

Now substitute in b+c = 1/3.

b+1/4 = 1/3.
b = 1/12 hence it takes 12 hours.

Sagar raut said:   10 years ago
A's 1 day work is 1/4.

A and B 1 day work is 1\3.

So 1/(A+B)-1\A = 1\B.

1\3 - 1\4 = 1\12.

NARESH PAL said:   10 years ago
(A + B) - B = B + C (A and B, C works equal).

1/10 - B = B + C.

1/2B = 1/10 - 1/50.

B = 25.

Saurabh said:   10 years ago
Following method focuses on avoiding fractions as much as possible, because calculating with fractions takes longer amount of time than calculating with integers.

In most problems on work-time-rate, fractions can be avoided altogether, or at least the role of fractions can be minimized.

Solution:

Assume total work = LCM (4, 3, 2) units = 12 units.

A's time = 4 hr.

==> A's rate = 12 units/4 hr = 3 units/hr.....(1).

(B+C)'s time = 3 hr.

==> B's rate + C's rate = 12 units/3 hr = 4 units/hr.....(2).

(A+C)'s time = 2 hr.

==> A's rate + C's rate = 12 units/2 hr = 6 units/hr.....(3).

From (1) and (3),

C's rate = 6-3 = 3 units/hr.....(4).

From (2) and (4),

B's rate = 4-3 = 1 unit/hr.

Hence B's time = Total work/B's rate = 12/1 = 12 hours.

Note: If you want to avoid spending time calculating the LCM, you can do so by saying that total amount of work = 4x3x2 = 24 units. Further calculations will change accordingly, but final answer will still be 12 hours.

The trick is "Don't define the total work to be simply 1 unit". Whenever the total work is defined to be 1 unit, fractions are introduced in the solution almost inevitably. Instead, we keep the total amount of work problem specific, and choose the total number of units to be the multiplication (or LCM) of suitable numbers.

While there is no guarantee that the fractions will be avoided altogether, they will at least be reduced to a large extent. In many cases, even some complicated ratios can be avoided by this method.

I will try to post as many solutions as I can using this method.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.