Aptitude - Alligation or Mixture - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Alligation or Mixture - General Questions (Q.No. 14)
14.
8 litres are drawn from a cask full of wine and is then filled with water. This operation is performed three more times. The ratio of the quantity of wine now left in cask to that of water is 16 : 65. How much wine did the cask hold originally?
18 litres
24 litres
32 litres
42 litres
Answer: Option
Explanation:

Let the quantity of the wine in the cask originally be x litres.

Then, quantity of wine left in cask after 4 operations = x 1 - 8 4  litres.
x

x(1 - (8/x))4 = 16
x 81

1 - 8 4 = 2 4
x 3

x - 8 = 2
x 3

3x - 24 = 2x

x = 24.

Discussion:
96 comments Page 4 of 10.

Kola.shiva said:   1 decade ago
Simple method.

8 liters of original wine drawn from the cask.

So question they had given at last the ratio is 16:65.

So we add recent 8 liters to present ratio of wine.

16+8 = 24. Simple.
(1)

Yogi damle said:   1 decade ago
If the answer is 24 liters then we cannot take out 8 liters of wine 4 times.

Murali said:   1 decade ago
After n operations the wine left is {(x-8)^n}/x^n-1.

However, at the end of every cycle the total quantity is x. Therefore quantity of water left after n operations is x-quantity of wine left= x-{(x-8)^n}/x^n-1.

Now, dividing quantity of wine left by quantity of water left we get: {(x-8)^n}/{x^n-(x-8)^n} = 16/65. Substitute each one of the options n see which one matches rather than going to solve this complex expression.

PRAVU said:   1 decade ago
Note that in each drawing, we take out 8/x part of the remaining wine and every time the total (wine +water) is x litre.

In 1st draw, pure wine is (x-8) i.e. x(1-8/x).

In 2nd draw, pure wine is (x-8)-(8/x)(x-8) i.e x(1-8/x)^2.

Similarly in 4th draw pure wine is x(1-8/x)^4.

Wine:water=16:65 or wine:total = 16:81.
(note: 16+65 = 81).

So, x(1-x)^4/x = 16/81.

PRAVU said:   1 decade ago
@Sanjay.

Pure wine is divided by total amount in the vessel, i.e. x.

So, pure wine: water = 16:65 OR it can be said as pure wine:total = 16:(16+65) = 16:81

Note that in each operation the total is always x litre.

Pandit said:   1 decade ago
Lets,
The volume of the drum is x.

In 1st operation 8 liter is drawn.
Remaining pure wine is x-8.

Now. If we draw whole volume = the volume of wine is drawn is x-8.

""""""""""''' 1 unit volume="""""""""""""""""""""""""" (x-8) /x.

""""""""""'''8 unit volume=""""""""""""""""""""""""""8*(x-8) /x.

The volume of wine remaining after 1st operation is (x-8) -{8* (x-8) /x} = { (x-8) ^2}/x...

Similarly in 4th draw pure wine is x (1-8/x) ^4.

PUNITH MISHRA P said:   1 decade ago
It is like this:

x(1-(8/x)^4)-(1) gives quantity of wine, whereas final ratio is 16/81. So final wine quantity is (16/81)*x which is equal to (1).

Nishad raut said:   1 decade ago
65 is given and 16 is assumed..so ans is assumed..
join my classes to become aptitude expert..

Pallavi Jha said:   1 decade ago
Can anyone explain why it is divided by x?

Rupesh said:   1 decade ago
Answer for x.
As the ratio is 16/65 (Wine:Water).

So the amount wine/total mixture = 16/65+16 = 16/81.
Here x = 81.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.