# Verbal Reasoning - Blood Relation Test - Discussion

### Discussion :: Blood Relation Test - Blood Relation 1 (Q.No.17)

17.

A and B are children of D. Who is the father of A? To answer this question which of the statements (1) and (2) is necessary?

1. C is the brother of A and the son of E.
2. F is the mother B.

 [A]. Only (1) [B]. Only (2) [C]. Either (1) or (2) [D]. (1) and (2) both

Explanation:

A and B are children of D.

From (1), C is the brother B and son of E.

Since, the sex of D and E are not known. Hence (1) is not sufficient to answer the question.

From (2). F is the mother of B. Hence, F is also the mother of A. Hence D is the father of A.

Thus, (2) is sufficient to answer the question.

 Kumar said: (Mar 8, 2016) From (1) it is known that A, B and C are children of A and E. But as sex of A and E are not known, so we can not say who is the father and who is the mother.

 Kumar said: (Mar 8, 2016) (1) and (2) can not be considered simultaneously.

 Goopal said: (Sep 29, 2016) I think the answer is Only (1).

 Samreen said: (Dec 4, 2016) If A and D are the children of D then according to the question we need to find the father of A. Hence we can consider D as the mother and so according to first option if C is brother of A and son of E then E could be father of A.

 Brajesh Tiwari said: (Apr 2, 2017) The answer is D. Because both statement sets a relationship.

 Swathi said: (Jun 29, 2017) If the answer is D then who is E?

 Ankur Tripathi said: (Aug 9, 2017) D who is a father of A So D is a male. Statement : C is the brother of A and the son of E. (which means C is male, A is son so again A is male, E can be female because there's a only father in above statement. if C is sister of A - E can be mother as female and A&E will he husband wife. I will go with Option 3 (either 1 or 2). Correct me if I'm wrong.

 Rushali said: (Apr 25, 2019) It has been said that A & B are children of D= D is the father as, F is mentioned as the mother of B. Then she could be the mother of A too as A & B are children of the same parent father. Hence F= Mother & D=Father. Answer B.