Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
|Potty Singh said: (May 7, 2016)|
|Women or men it does not matter it's the point of view and all have immense potential and creativity to manage as we know that behind every successful man there is a women all work hard be awesome.|
|Heer Rajput said: (Apr 29, 2016)|
I agree with all points but according to my point of view, women are best managers because they balance their life with parents as well as the organisation also In both places she showed their talent in a similar manner and she balanced it.
|Prashant said: (Apr 14, 2016)|
|I think both are same in achieving the goal. If anyone wants something then he or she must possess managerial quality.|
|Kml Srma said: (Apr 7, 2016)|
|In my point of view, skills of a person don't depend on gender. Everybody has the same potential, the same mind it matter how they use it. So by working hard, doing regular work and keeping an eye on goal than everybody can become a good manager.|
|Titan said: (Apr 5, 2016)|
|In my point of view before achieving any position, women's have to become mentally strong because our women's are very emotional, they become very emotional when she take a strong decision.|
|Amit said: (Mar 24, 2016)|
|As per me my opinion it is baseless to compare man and woman for a post. Managerial responsibility requires talent, good understanding, managing skills, communication skill. If any person either man or woman has these characteristics he or she can be a good manager.
In short those who possess managerial quality they can be a good manager.
Although I agree that there are more men managers than women and the reason is our society attitude towards women. Women are understood as homemaker only and not allowed to live their dreams. If we give opportunity and treat everybody equally without any gender discrimination then women will show their talent in every field and can shoulder all responsibility as men do.
|Anu said: (Feb 23, 2016)|
I am agree with all points but according to my point of view women are best managers because they balance their life with parents as well as organisation also In both places she showed their talent in a similar manner and she balanced it.
|Aishu Sindgikar said: (Feb 17, 2016)|
I agree with all but according to me women are good manager because they always think profit and loss before starting any work so they can manage any task in good manner but man never think before starting any work so women is the best in work.
|Rounak Gupta said: (Jan 10, 2016)|
|I think women be a good manager because she has more thinking power than man like when she any work she thinks before about that work than men and also she manage her home and if women have good knowledge, talented n also have to manage then it can be a good manager.
And we have so example like Indira Gandhi -she was the first woman prime minister of India, Pratibha Patel, Mother Teresa, Arundhati Roy.
|Saint said: (Oct 19, 2015)|
|All I'm asking is that if women's are so talented, then why are they so outnumbered in that aspect, i.e. only 2% as CEO's and CMD's, and 20% in top managerial position, please someone enlighten me, and don't say its because of male dominance, because its the law of nature that the fittest dominate, so all you will be saying is that men are better.
And if you are about to say that its because they didn't get a chance, well I have got news for you, you never will, chances never come to you, you have to go to them. And when you say of names like Indira Gandhi, Indira Nooyi, Chanda Kochar, Pratibhatai Patil, Meira Kumar, Arundhati Bhattacharya, you can even compare those name with what I have to say, name that even you will agree with I'm not saying that women are bad managers, all I'm saying is that men make a better one.
|Prince Pathak said: (Oct 15, 2015)|
|I partially agree with all. But according to me women are good manager because they always think profit and loss before starting any work so they can manage any task in good manner but man never think before starting any work.|
|Aakash Roy said: (Oct 3, 2015)|
|Good evening friends.
Yes I do believe that women can make up a good manager but it is totally inappropriate to make such gender distinctions. A person having good knowledge, creativity, ability to manage people and also can evolve them altogether to achieve a prominent goal for the organization then he/she can be a good manager. In this context yes I truly believe that women can be a good managers because this is proved day and day out by the women we are surrounded with, it can be our mother, grandmother anyone.
WOMEN do possess this multitasking attitude in them from the ancient times. We are surrounded by some famous examples of leading ladies like Arundhati Bhattacharya the first chairperson of the STATE BANK OF INDIA, Chanda Kochhar the CEO of ICICI bank, Meira Kumar the first women speaker of Lok Sabha and the last but not the least Pratibhatai Patil the first women president of the independant INDIA. So I feel if a WOMEN CAN MANAGE A COUNTRY THAN WHY NOT A COMPANY AND BUSINESS?
|Vinod Janwa said: (Sep 25, 2015)|
|I think that women is better manager because she does a lot of all work morning to till the sleep. Man can't do all work till the sleep. Man can't do work at home. If I talk about out of house work so women is also keep passing with man. Woman are also giving her service in military, hospitality, politics, film industries, banks, school, colleges, many private and govt companies. And they are also doing work at home. They are going ahead. I think that women is better manager.|
|Kiran said: (Sep 21, 2015)|
|My opinion was Men only make good managers, but it was proved wrong already if we take examples of Indira Gandhi, Pepsico CEO Indira Nooyi, ICICI CEO Chanda Kochar. They were and are hold good positions and proved themselves. Management doesn't available in books. It came with outside knowledge, So I thought men only can do it better, but now a days system has changed women also having equal IQ as men, so women also can do it better.
We can also take example of Jayalalita who has developed Tamil Nadu better than any male chief minister of Tamil Nadu. Now it is the most urbanized state in south India. So women are managing better than now a days.
|Susreeta said: (Sep 13, 2015)|
|I do think that managerial positions cannot be justified by gender difference. It all depends on the grasping ability of the persons to learn things, to have an effective communication in the work place, to have presence and dedication towards the post with a vision to lead the people to the organizational goals.
Should posses leadership qualities to manage people and environment surrounding him/her. Its totally baseless to say that gender differences is the main reason for a good manager.
|Deepak said: (Sep 1, 2015)|
|It is very big difference between managing home n company. Women is sensitive and getting easily emotional. Only few example of women listed out above. What about others. Not one said. My view is that women is only homemaker.
Government gives 33 percent reservation but conditions of women till now is same, who is responsible only women because they feel they are only home maker. In Rajasthan, Punjab, Asama, Haryana, Jammu kashmir the % of women in corporate sector is quite low.
|John said: (Aug 23, 2015)|
|I agree that women are better managers because they have a lot of patience and whatever work they do they give their best.|
|Martha said: (Aug 21, 2015)|
|Women are better managers because they value employees rights and opinions and are ready give support to the crew without undermining anyone.|
|Neha said: (Aug 14, 2015)|
@Nisha said very true.
Yes well in my opinion definitely women is a good manager because she has a potential to manage the thing. It's a known fact that women are more organised then men and women's are most of time effectively handle all domestic responsibilities even in the financial domain.
|Shine said: (Aug 7, 2015)|
|Woman is the most beautiful creation of god. She has the power to take tough decisions better than a man as she is well organised and can keep everything in order. So indeed a woman can take better take decision hen man as she has the caliber to handle the position of a manager very well and effectively.|
|T.Dharmadurai said: (Jul 30, 2015)|
|Most of the women create their own placement in every field that means finally what I am telling, Women can handle the problems in every field then why can't handle the small organization and Kalpana Chawla? Its a joke right, because the last time I checked she was no manager or entrepreneur, and why would you call her a legend because she is a women or because she is an Indian, or because she died in a space shuttle crash, meant no this respect.
If she's a legend what would you say about Neil Armstrong (First man to moon) or Yuri Gagarin (First man to outer space). And for the record there were 5 men and 2 women's in Columbia (5>2).
|Dharmadurai T said: (Jul 30, 2015)|
|In my point is men manager better than women manager because the men manager doing any work in without mistake, fear which processed are do in quickly.|
|Aaruz said: (Jul 13, 2015)|
|Women are always good managers. Because she need to look her parents, husband's parents, husband, siblings, children, if cattle's its too. If she got a job she is capable of managing it too. So women are the good managers. Behind the success of every man there is a women.|
|Apoorva Mishra said: (Jun 15, 2015)|
|Very happy to see these sort of answers, but I think it would be injustice with women only if we say that they are better manager, they can do each and everything if given a CHANCE to prove themselves. There are number of ladies in my life whom I admire and seen them working so hard and they manage everything with so ease. That possibly men can't even think of it.|
|Harry said: (Jun 12, 2015)|
|By looking at people like Kiran Bedi, Indira Gandhi, Sheila Dikshit who have managed the people so well we cannot deny the fact that women can't be good managers. Moreover what I believe is that nothing is impossible, if someone has the ability and if he/she works hard for it then he/she will surely achieve it.
So becoming a manager totally depends upon the qualities a person posses and the hard work done by him/her but not on the gender of that person.
|Lucky said: (Jun 4, 2015)|
Woman is a best manager than men woman are all rounder and woman has got many power like talent, skills, convincing power, definitely patience, and preservation we can handle problem effectively yes Indira Gandhi is an example of woman.
|Mercy said: (Jun 3, 2015)|
The topic itself brings out a separation between the gender. Everyone has the capacity to do all sort of work. It never varies on seeing the gender. People come up with the chances they get. When chances provided everyone can become a good manager.
I would conclude saying that work never varies based on gender, only on the chances and their capacity.
|Mark said: (May 25, 2015)|
Yes I agree with the fact that women make good managers. But It would be inappropriate to discriminate talent on the basis of gender. Any one who posses the qualities like creativity, knowledge, commitment, versatility, discipline etc can become a good managers. But talking about the topic of our discussion I think women are way better than men in managing more than one stuff at a time.
You know back in ancient days men would go into the forest for hunt and the women used to do all the stuffs like taking care of kids, agriculture work, household chores etc. So It shows that women are better at managing things from those days.
Talking about the present scenario, Indra Nooyi, CEO of pepsico, Arundhati Bhattacharya, first women to be the chairperson of State Bank Of India, Chanda Kochhar, CEO of ICICI bank, Pratibhatai Patil, first women president of Independent India, Meira Kumar, first women speaker of Lok sabha. I think these are the best example to prove that women make good managers.
|Harika said: (May 24, 2015)|
|In my opinion either man or woman can be the good manager. It all depends on his/her mind set, ability, exposure to situations, communication etc. People just say that only men or women are good managers. It is because some situations made them think like that. No wrong in their opinions too.
People who support men are thinking that men are good managers because til now many reputed, goodwill earned companies have only men as CEO's, top level managers. So basing on this they concluded that men are good managers. People supporting women because they manage home, family, office etc. men cannot do that.
But I won't support only men or only women. Because to be good managers first chance is to be given to prove that they are the good managers. If women are employed in top position in companies they will prove them selves and they have proved it. Men can also be good house managers and they are even doing that so today every woman can go and work.
Finally both men and women will be the good managers but the only thing is chance should be given to prove themselves.
|Nisha said: (May 21, 2015)|
|If you ask my point of view I would say definitely they can make good managers because our society neglected women from the past to perform any outdoor activities. They were forced to manage house, husband, children and cooking all the times.
Women took that job as a challenge and now their achievement is if anybody ask a women can you cook? Can you manage house, children, husband etc. Then anyone can say you are asking a stupid question. She is a woman and that is inbuilt in her.
Now think for a while and say if the management work was provided to women, they would have done justice to the same job, not because they are good managers but they are sincere and efficient to perform any duty.
|Luqman said: (May 16, 2015)|
|Educating women can bring up great changes in a country like India because if women are educated they can change the world as they will not be dependent on their husband's for buying anything as women will be earning in the highly qualified company.|
|Bhaveshw said: (May 14, 2015)|
|I thinks that, women & men both are same capabilities to handle an organization & its totally depends upon to whom we are giving more chance or responsibilities & how we encourage them, if give chance to women to handle organization, she will definitely give more result & output then any man. Women are more organized than man. So it is totally false that only men are good manager.|
|Venkatesh said: (Apr 29, 2015)|
|I think both men and women are best managers, but why man only having more percentage than women is, we are not giving chance to them, to prove what they are, if we give chances to them also then we can see the equal percentage between men and women. Not only in management but in kinds of works. So, their is no chance that men only good manger, both are equal only.|
|Ajay Kumar said: (Apr 18, 2015)|
|In my point of view I personally think think that women is far better than men because if you see the whole life of a women than you see that she have to face many relation in her life firstly she is a daughter who have to live in certain limit and at the same time she have to study and do household chores also and after that when she get married than she become mother and she have to look up both families and her child which her husband to fulfill all the desires ect, so the women are inherent from the childhood only she can have a better management then men.|
|Jyotsana Tripathi said: (Apr 4, 2015)|
|From the ancient time people underestimate women and think them as a machine for all of their household works. They were categorized in the line of animals as you know the lines of Tulsidas.
According to my opinion women are best managers. Do not go far for the example but see in your own house how your mother, sister or wife manages in those situations when you are confused what to do and for more information about women's capability you must read history of India and you must have a friendly mentality about women too.
|Jeyaraj said: (Feb 26, 2015)|
|By reading this discussion you guys are supporting or saying the women can be a best manager. All the points what you said are all OK. You guys don't have confident on yourself?They manage both family and work so that then can be a best manager.
My simple question is that in our home if we want to take any financial decision we discuss it to our father not only financial but also for many major decisions. So that a man can be good decision maker. By this I say that man is a best manager than women.
|Sanjoy Das said: (Feb 21, 2015)|
|Before starting the discussion I would like to explain the word what actually manager means. A manager is a person who manage every thing, take care the organisational profit, set up a link between his or her employee for further progress of company or organisation. So the definition reflect the post or the designation is not depend upon gender or sexuality.
A Person having a good responsibility, personality, ethics, capability of understanding the fact, leadership quality and communication skill can groom himself or herself for the post of the manager.
In Indian economical market there is a plenty no. of example where the managerial post are hold by men and woman simultaneously. Chanda Kochhar is the MD of ICICI bank, Arundhuti Bhattacharya plays a top role in SBI BANK, KIRAN MAZUMDER-SHAW is the MD of Biocon Limited.
On the other we can name Kumar Mangalam Birla, Harse Neotia, Mukesh Ambani as a good manger. So my point is that a deserving person should hold the right position beyond of any sort of sexual reservation.
|Saint said: (Feb 2, 2015)|
|@"Gender discrimination and male domination are hindering the females" - Gender discrimination? you are kidding right, all I see around is reservations and special treatments for women's, whether it be government post or a seat in the parliament, and talking about the domination, well its the law of nature that fittest dominate.
@"In Rajasthan women's are making papad" - wow now what do I say to that, you are doing a marvelous job.
@"Womens are good at house hold activity" - if you think house hold work and being a Entrepreneur is the same thing, you have no idea what you talking about.
@"Women are playing a key role in every field as CEO and CMD" - women's are only 2% of the CEO's and only about 20% of top managerial level all over the company, and if you think that is the key role, you have got to work on your mathematics skills.
When you say that women's are wonderful managers and find them so badly outnumbered in that aspect, don't you think something is wrong with your whole argument there, its like saying that snail has all qualities for being a good runner, but out there they don't run.
|Vikas Nagargoje said: (Jan 29, 2015)|
|I think it's not depends up on gender. Its depend up on the ability, skill, good knowledge of management. Both have same brain. Mind capacity depend up on hard work about these things. I agree now a days women are good organisation and good management. Women are good manager.|
|Kundan said: (Jan 21, 2015)|
|Yes I'm in favour of this statement. Women have the inbuilt ability to manage things efficiently. The example is the housewife. She has a list of things in her hand to do, like looking after the children, making them ready for school, preparing lunch/breakfast for them and for her husband. After she finishes her morning tasks, she has to then look after the house cleanliness or at the kitchen stocks.
So these sequential work automatically makes her efficient in performing the tasks. Therefore it can also be said that women are good at multitasking. So when it comes to an Organisation, they can apply their inherent traits. She has to deal with a lot of corporate relationships, employees, etc as according to her position in the organisation.
As someone said already, it is a fact that women are more calm and patient than men, ya but there are some exceptions where this point fails. They are also able to manage by virtue of their good communication skills and soft voice.
My conclusion is that women are better managers than men as seen in general but from personal point of view anyone (whether male or female) can be a good manager provided he has achieved the basic skills required through training or practice.
|Meenu Garg said: (Jan 19, 2015)|
|According to me women are better managers because they need not built this quality rather it is inherit in them. How as women are naturally proves to be the best person in managing the household activities. So if they are given chance to manage the organization they will prove to be the best managers.
Because they have the quality of managing different kind of persons at a particular point of time. For e.g. She knows it very well how to solve conflicts b/w two people, how to meet the different demands of employees etc.
|Preethi Komal said: (Jan 18, 2015)|
|According to my opinion, now-a-days women plays a key role in every field and in every organisation as bank CEOs and CMDs. In this year women of some organisations are the awareness of FICCI. So, the women make the management in any field.|
|Abhay Pandey said: (Jan 9, 2015)|
|AS far as good managers are concerned, one who leads and helps others to prosper in his group or organisation is said to be possessing qualities of good manager. By saying this, I meant that given topic is not based on gender. Good manager requires ethics, personality, leadership quality, communication etc. Since all these qualities can be possessed by any of the male/female managers. (For eg. Arudhanti bhattacharya, Kiran majumdar shaw, Chanda kocher, Indra nooyi, steve jobs, Bill gates, Mukesh ambani etc. ).
So my point of saying is that good managers requires hard work, exceptional talent and out of box thinking. A person or human who have above all qualities develop himself to be a good managers.
|Kinjal said: (Jan 5, 2015)|
|According to me, there are many society are run with the help of women only and it is wonders to hear that because of women, our country is on ranking position.|
|Renee said: (Jan 3, 2015)|
|From my point of, the term good manager is not related to gender. Either man/women become good manager with their knowledge their skills, their management skills With good quality of quick decision, loving nature, patients, not quickly aggressive and better ability to convince to people easily then man is the positive nature of women.
And women have to understand sometimes without any saying other people. Women are good at mind reading very easily.
So my conclusion of this is that by various skills, More and more knowledge good communication skills people can make good manager.
|Rahul Chauhan said: (Dec 19, 2014)|
|Obviously Women are good managers. Gender discrimination and male dominance are hindering the females to step ahead and prove themselves. Otherwise, Women are born manager because whether it's a mom or a daughter or a wife.
A women always manages everything better. We can see examples such as in Rajasthan few women had started making papad and later their recipe is famous in all over the world. They now brought millions of turnover and helps in developing countries economy. The name of the company is "Lijjat papad".
So, its not matter whether you are male or female, the think matter is the managerial aspect and core knowledge in your respective fields.
Regarding the issues that many friends have mentioned earlier that Women physique are weak. So, they don't able to handle the field works. With the advancement in technology in today's era. Everything is automated and their are males who work under managers. So, individually if they are unable to complete the task, then team work will help it. As management is also about team work or working in a group.
So, if The developing country want to be a develop country. Than it has to make a mindset "No gender discrimination". And both men as well as women should support equally for the nation's bright future. Which makes us best one day.
|Saint said: (Dec 12, 2014)|
|Someone said "Gender is not factor to determine the managerial capacity", the why the numbers (there are only 2% women CEO) suggest otherwise, don't tell me men dominate, its the law of nature that the fittest dominate, and if you say men dominate then what you really mean is that men dominate.
@ "Now scenario has changed" - the present women make less than 20% of top managerial position in spite of all reservation and special treatment, and if what you mean is that in future women will outnumber men, then come to me when that happen,
@ "Women are more balanced and loving" - really never heard of buddha, jesus, or vivrkananda, name a women who have done it better,
@ "Women manage home and office" - well what can I say to that, good luck with that,
@ "Women list is endless, don't underestimate them" - nobody is underestimating the, but you should come and see the men's list its much bigger.
@ "Both have same brains" - then why such a big disparity in accomplishment.
@ "Prathiba patil, ekata kapoor and other names that I not heard" - really those are best names you have got, can you even compare those names with gandhi, edison, steve jobs or alexander.
|Pranav Shukl said: (Nov 29, 2014)|
|According to me man is good manager than woman because man is do everything like he can do work something to absent worker but women it can not be survive it woman is become only for people attraction but she is not a good manager.|
|David Sam said: (Nov 28, 2014)|
|Hello friends I know that to become a manager is not a cake walk but its also not depend upon gender. Its depend upon ability and skills. And I agree that a woman should be a good manager.|
|Afreen said: (Nov 21, 2014)|
|Women are better than men because they have more patients than men. They work hard well.|
|Umakanta Sasmal said: (Nov 4, 2014)|
|Hi friends, I am Umakanta Sasmal (from Santoshpur, Ganjam). In my view women can also be a good manager because they are talented and capable, & they can contribute to the growth of that organization. To become a good manager is not depend on gender it depends upon their ability &adroitness.
As we know there are less women managers than men because women's role remains confined to the traditional roles of homemakers engaged in looking after the household and child rearing. If they are encouraged by their family & by govt providing some amenities. Ensure that they will be a good manager.
|Umesh Khadela said: (Oct 27, 2014)|
I am Umesh, Umesh khadela from NIPER, Mohali.
First of I am totally agree with the given topic that women can be good managers, because from the starting of their life they used to manage so many things like they have to do house work with educational life. With job they have to handle her parent family and after marriage also they have to handle two family and all work.
So managerial skills are inherently available in the women, but those who shows it to the outer world they can be good managers.
Also mentality of indians are now changing, they are giving equal importance to women in decision making process. And that's why more women managers are coming into pictures.
i.e. Kiran mazumdar.
And so many.
In the end, I will conclude that women possess the capacity to be a good manager but thing is they should get chance to show their capabilities.
|K.Bhargavi said: (Oct 17, 2014)|
|Yes, women can also be a good manager because women's are also developing their communication skills, equal to men, then how can we say that women's are not fit for managers.|
|Lakshmi said: (Oct 10, 2014)|
|Yes, I agree with my friend's point. Women can be a good manager than the men. To become a good manager, a person require excellent skills, intelligence, fast decision making and all these things depend on his/her education, environment around him/her. Nobody whether its men or women are born managers.|
|Deepa said: (Oct 3, 2014)|
In my point of view Both have good managers dependence up on their knowledge. Both have same brains. For example if any problem is there who take the right decision at right time then only we decide who is the good manager. But comparing with men women have good patience. And she is maintain both family and office with equal importance.
And one thing olden days women's are only on home so much of problem but now the trend will be change and each and every sector compete with men and she get success.
|Prasad Shinde said: (Sep 17, 2014)|
|Ya I agree, women are the best managers. As there are many examples it will take plenty of time to take their name. So keeping it aside. Talking about their work doing ability, sense of humor. And many more things make them best.|
|Saurabh said: (Sep 9, 2014)|
|As many of my colleagues already pointed out the managing ability of men and women, yes we can say that its not gender but skills and ability to develop and practice these skills is sought and on this basis a manager is selected, whether it is male/female.
As the quote "leaders are born not made" is passe now a days, the paradigm that only men can be managers is out of date because in recent years, women already proved that they have all the abilities and can prove if they had given a chance.
Katrina and priyanka.
All proved that they have ability and they can lead and perform well.
|Vasundhra Mahajan said: (Aug 19, 2014)|
|Well the art of managing cannot be restricted by gender. Skills are to be learned and practiced. Men or women both, can be expert with their opinions or judgements. But when it comes to framing any policy, designing a new framework, thinking of more economical means or managing a weird situation, I think opinion of women can also matter. I don't say women are better rather women should be given proper chance of letting out her views and trying her techniques of management. She may not perform better than men but she can perform equally well if given a chance. The more good managers (men or women) we have, the better it is.|
|Sayali said: (Aug 13, 2014)|
|Hi, this is Sayali. I think women are better than men because of having good patience, hearing ability without which it is difficult to manage employees as well as customers or clients. It creates a sense of loyalty among your colleagues and make them passionate to work for your project. Men mostly believe in action than words which is the symbol of arrogance, rudeness etc. This is the quality which make your partners go away from you. Thus, women are better than men.|
|Rutuja said: (Jul 28, 2014)|
|As I have gone through the above points many boys were supporting women. Well that's nice it gives positive hope and feeling of living in 21st century, thank you so much friends. Yes I do agree that a good manager does not depends upon gender and it completely depends upon different skills that are required to be the good manager. There are some work which a women can do better and some work which man can do better.
But I am not agree with friend who has given lots of examples because though it shows us a man is a good manager but this doesn't proves that a women is a bad one, it shows that you are biased.
Well there are few examples have a look my friend.
1. Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw is an Indian entrepreneur. She is the Chairman & Managing Director of Biocon Limited a biotechnology company based in Bangalore (Bengaluru), India.
2. Ekta Jeetendra Kapoor (b. 7 June 1975) is an Indian TV and film producer. She is the Joint Managing Director and Creative Director of Balaji Telefilms, her production company.
3. Swati A. Piramal is the Vice Chairperson of Piramal Lifesciences Limited and Director of Piramal Healthcare Limited. Dr. Piramal received one of India's highest civilian honour, the Padma Shri award, by the President of India, Ms. Pratibha Patil on 4th April, 2012 She has been nominated as one of the 25 Most Powerful Business Women in India eight times and is now a member of the Hall of Fame of the Most Powerful Women.
4. Rajshree Pathy, is an eminent entrepreneur from Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, India. She is the Chairperson and Managing Director of the Rajshree Group of Companies and Founder of India Design Forum.
5. Radhika Roy is an Indian media baron and co Chairperson and Managing Director, NDTV. Radhika has won the Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year award for Information, Communication and Entertainment in the year 2003. .
The list is endless. So don't under estimate women. Women and men both can be the good manager only because of their skills and not because of the history of managers.
|Aakash Kumar said: (Jul 26, 2014)|
|I think, men are best manager than women, because if women's are best managers, then why number of women managers are less than men manages. So we can say men's having good managing quality than woman.|
|Zoya said: (Jul 21, 2014)|
|Women possess the skills of managing things. Women are already proved to be best managers. On the other side of the coin there is no skill that can't be taught and learnt to someone irrespective of the gender. Its only practice that makes them good at what they do.|
|Rohith said: (Jul 12, 2014)|
|I think that women are good managers because no men will not run the family as well as a women. A family itself it needs the women "without a women a men wouldn't be" without a men a women would be. Not only that the other quality i.e., their sincerity, hard working skills will make her a good managers.|
|Karuna said: (Jul 11, 2014)|
|Well, I think both men and women can be good manager depending upon the talent, leadership skill, communication skill, decision making. And he or she should have capability to manage situation. So there is no point in making difference.|
|Ssp said: (Jul 2, 2014)|
|What we require to be a good manager is that good decision making, good communication, motivation to employees and manage the entire business and produce maximum output with minimum input and improve productivity so why there is question of men and women? Despite the fact is that women have ability to manage her family from her childhood so she can not manage business.|
|Manali Chowdhury said: (Jun 19, 2014)|
|Well my perspective towards this kind of statement is quite biased since I m not regardless of the feminist opinions, but the society has changed drastically and men are gradually being comprehensive about the priorities of women. In certain parts of India, people still hold patriarchal views, where women are still confined to the walls of their house and are expected to perform the domestic chores and cater to the needs of their family and spouse. Women turn out to be to better managers on professional as well as on personal grounds due to their perseverance and an inherent quality which is ingrained in them since their childhood.
Somewhere they are being mentally prepared to face such situations. We can't be negligent of the fact that even men these days do contribute some time out of their professional life to give time to family. Though the majority still lies with women for when it comes to sacrificing their ambitions for the upbringing of their wards its women who step forth. Men generally look after the external matters.
This is also because it is a pre conceived notion that mother can take better care of children than father, whereas it is not always so. Despite of being a woman I don't completely agree to this as several explanations can still be provided. I'm sure even the women/girls reading this agree that fathers take care of the family silently and are not expressive about their contribution whereas women are somewhat boastful about their importance and role in family.
|Anushka said: (May 22, 2014)|
|Dear friends in my opinion we are living in 21 century, so we can not distinguish between men and woman, now woman managing job and home together, she doing everything perfect in any field, few year ago people was think -work done by men can not be done by women. But now days it is in vice-Versa. The CEO of google is a women and so many field they are giving their best.
Before some year there was no facility for woman. She was not educated so many restriction as compare to boys but after providing facility she uses of this facility very well. That's by our C.M. Providing many scheme for girls they can be become the part of our nation.
In conclusion I would like to say managerial skills not denpends on gender. One who has the ability who will be good manager.
|Viswesh said: (Mar 18, 2014)|
|Dude now the world is changed and why do people stick on to the traditional beliefs that only men can become good managers ? Those who possess the managerial talents, skills and ability to coordinate can become managers. Its not immaterial that only men can be the good managers. Nowadays womens are also equally talented than that of men in all aspects, so its nothing that like only men can become good managers. Infact womens take quick decisions than that of men and obviously they are successful in their work. So I just wanna conclude by saying that don't just simply criticize women, because they can do anything and everything.|
|Sh03 said: (Mar 17, 2014)|
|Being a good manager is completely gender neutral.
It depends on one's ability to make decisions, work in pressure situations, one's knowledge and so on.
Women are good in multi tasking but that cannot be a concluding statement for "women are better managers". It is one the positive points they possess.
Similarly, men are better at handling emotions than women but this cannot be a deciding statement for who is a better manager. This is simply one of their strengths.
In conclusion, it depends on one's ability and not gender on who is a better manager.
|Himani said: (Feb 28, 2014)|
|Yes, Definitely a woman can a good manager. We can easily see this by taking an example like a woman can mange their office with their home. She handle all responsibility of home while working a job. As woman has a more convincing power than Man, more patience than man, more polite than man even in communication field a woman is better than a man, so how can we say that a woman can not be a good manager.|
|Rinkita said: (Feb 26, 2014)|
|You can not generalize this statement!
It can not be treated as a fact which will remain universal truth or false, NO Matter what. Like, Square of two is 4, NO MATTER WHAT!
There are certain field, where woman have proved to be good managers. Those needed qualities to be a good manager like Good comm. Skills, convincing power, and definitely Patience and perseverance, are more found in women, compared to men.
Examples can be from your neighborhood or your family. A working women make sure her kids reach to school on time, get their meal, her husband gets his stuffs and goes to office on time. This whole along with her office work, is something men can't do, even if practiced for years!
But, Yes. When it comes to Field work, such as in a Factory or a Construction Site, a Woman is definitely going to face all the possible problems regarding work and workers. Toughest for her to handle a Strike, which is quite in Factories, though she got better convincing power, but, it will be very hard for her to invest that skill completely.
But, yes when it comes to jobs, where people behave much more sophisticate (may be because they have to) , Women have proven to be better managers comparatively.
And we should definitely not forget the power of smile :) ;).
|Deep said: (Feb 19, 2014)|
|Today, we are discussing about the topic that "do women make good manager". Here we focus only one keyword i.e.good manager. A person become a good manager if he have a leadership skill, good managerial skill, good communicational skill and so on. We cannot say that men are better manager. Now a days we found that women have also the skills like managerial skill, communicational skill, etc. They are more organised than men. They easily handle the any situation as compared to men.
She is one of the most successful president in our country. She has very good leadership and managerial skill.
Sometimes we can also say that they have more convinced power rather than men.
Now a days most of the shopping mall hire the women because they easily sell the any product as compared to men.
But we can also that they have a emotional power. They cannot balance the personal and professional relationship.
|Varsha said: (Jan 8, 2014)|
|Women can also become good managers. To become a good manager is not dependent on gender. It requires various skills like good managerial skills, communication skills, leaderships skills etc. In present area Women are equally competent to men so gender is not at core to decide whether a women can be a good manager. Of course women can be very good managers.|
|Sneha said: (Dec 28, 2013)|
|Indian WOMEN ARE CONSIDERED more balanced on emotional aspect than Indian men and definitely they are able to handle various situations in a more better way as in modern era we can witness them handling their homes and offices effectively. If given a managerial post which is much about taking decisions and managing people of the organisation they will surely deliver it in a more proper way due to their balanced EQ and IQ as well.|
|Sneha Singh said: (Dec 15, 2013)|
|I think that its a neutral topic. Because in some of the cases women are not to seen as good managers. Well. I'm not criticizing women. Most of the women are emotional while taking some serious decision.
But some of the women are so good and quick in managing things even more than men. So I would like to conclude that managing skills doesn't depend upon gender. But rather depend upon intelligence. !
|Sarika said: (Dec 13, 2013)|
|Its always yes that women can be a good manager. Gender is not the factor to determine the managerial capacity. Its the skill, attitude, patience that make a person to be a good manager. Its true that in today's world women are outnumbered, but this is due to the existing orthodox society that always shows the women their limits.
But now the scenario has changed and more number of women coming out with their talent and placed themselves in top hierarchy of business equal to men. If its about majority then when it comes to handle both family and office women are more capable than men.
|Subin said: (Dec 2, 2013)|
|I see here that the failure of women's to be as par as men has been greatly attributed to the men domination in the past, I should say, an attempt to look for excuses, history is the witness that great people have risen to glory against all adds.
Beethoven that greatest of all composers was deaf.
Edison the greatest of all scientist was considered stupid by his teachers.
Bill Gates & Steve jobs the greatest contributors to this computer age didn't make to the college.
Stephen Hawkins the greatest exponent in the field of theoretical physics is completely paralysed.
Dr Abdul Kalam missile man of India and the peoples president was from a fisherman's family.
Winners have always found there way though problems, instead of blaming there failures on circumstances they stood against the odds and prevailed.
And moreover if you think about it humans have dominated over all creatures, because they were better, and if men have dominated women's the reason should obviously the same, It is the law of nature that the fittest dominate.
It have been pointed out that criteria to be a good manager is gender independent, I completely agree with it, but given that men make most of the management flock (especially top of the hierarchy) it seems that these quality are more likely to be found in a man.
And many claim that women play a great part in managing homes and children's, I beg to differ, and if I'm wrong prove me differently. (with facts, not for the sake of it. ).
Answer when women's here are solely credited with qualities like patience, preservation, love and compassion, you would like to be reminded of mahatma Gandhi, Nelson Mandela, Swami Vievekananda and Gautham budha. Oh yaa they were all men.
My Idea is not to imply anything here, but to know that if women's are so qualified, why so outnumbered (Only 2% of CEO in fortune 500 companies). And don't blame it on male dominance like I have explained it before.
|Ayana Kakoti said: (Nov 26, 2013)|
|Yes, I do agree that women are better managers than men as women has more patience and can handle problems effectively. Indira Gandhi is one of the example.|
|Pamu Love said: (Nov 9, 2013)|
|Yes according to me woman is a good manager in work place as well as at home. Today's scenario woman play important role in our society. Woman joining hand with the man. Nisha godrej and Roshni are the eg. Nisha Godrej, who received her undergraduate degree from wharton and haa a MBA form Harvard, started at the Godrej Group. She was recently appointed president of Human Capital and Innovation at the Godrej group. In this role, she will be in charge of managing more than 20,000 employees.|
|Sushma Kiran Mai said: (Oct 25, 2013)|
I will agree with all your views, concerns and opinions which are specifically said by you but don't you thing that every women cannot be a good manager she should have the all interpersonal skills to leading a company to monitoring the employees to interaction with each and every person in the concern then only she will become a good manager if this qualities are possessed by a women than only she will become good manager controlling a family is different and controlling a organization is different in organization we have to perform quick operations in any business organization and they can also that stability to perform in good and the best ways but where are the chances in corporate co.
So finally I want to tell that women are the good manager but they should have the effectiveness and efficiency and managerial skills then only they can be the best manager like chanda kohchar ceo of icici and she recently awarded as 3rd world strongest women. Jaya lalitha tamil nadu cm and in prehistory also we can find many more women managers like jahansi lakshmi bai indira gandhi etc so women is good manager.
|Resmi said: (Oct 23, 2013)|
|Management is purely based on skills, inherent quality, attitude etc it can nothing to do with gender, so it can be a man or woman, the one who is talented and ready to take risk will be a successful manager.|
|Anil said: (Oct 16, 2013)|
|In my point of view men and women both are good manager if they have leadership technical communication skills. Women be a good manager if she handle the situation they have convincing capacity. There are many women in our country or out of country become good manager.|
|Manoj said: (Oct 4, 2013)|
|In my opinion I think that if a women have giving a chance to specify their ability they can easily prove what they can do. It is a wrong thinking of people that women are not good a manger. We never forget these women Pratibha Patil & Rani Lakshmibai which plays an important role for the growth of nation.|
|Tej said: (Oct 2, 2013)|
|I have been pretty much amazed to read certain opinions which conclude with a sweeping statement "Women are better managers than Men".
I would say, Women are not given a fair chance in the corporate market due to a still existing orthodox feeling that Women can't survive in this tricky & confusing world which is absolutely wrong. We should come out of this traditional feeling of Men should do work & women should manage home. Women are good caretakers & have the natural ability of being careful & committed.
Conclusion :Women cannot be judge as being superior to men or vice-versa just because of certain natural abilities. Men can handle situations well where you need a "ROCK SOLID" heart & women can where it needs handling with sensitivity. So, both Men & women have their own merits & demerits in handling diversified roles of a Manager. Women or a Men who maintains the balance between their natural merits & demerits becomes a good manager. Becoming a Good manager is GENDER neutral & women should given equal opportunities & freedom both in corporate & personal life.
|Reka said: (Sep 12, 2013)|
|In my point of view women are good managers because they can handle all the problems easily & effectively with care & affection. If a women think me she can change everything in the world. In olden days also women are good managers because they handled all the situation effectively for Eg. RaniLakshmiBai, KasturbaGandhi, etc.|
|Ritu Porwal said: (Sep 11, 2013)|
|I totally agree with all points which are discussed above we all know behind every successful man there is a man but you people ever heard that behind a successful women there is a man. So in my point of view this is the main difference that women are good manager.|
|Raju said: (Sep 4, 2013)|
|The decisive factor is the potential of the person. If women has the potential to manage a particular firm she will make a good manager. But managing people in a firm needs different set of skills compered to that of managing a household.
Since the question here is 'do women make good managers?' I would say no as the gender of the person has nothing to do with management of a project. However I am not saying that men will make the best mangers just because they are men.
Again the mobility of women has serious constrains owing to the social situations and the roles she opt to play in her family. You cannot expect a married mother to stay back a bit longer to complete a particular task. So such things limit the scope and capacity of women in general.
|Kanimozhi said: (Sep 4, 2013)|
|Yes I agree with women are good managers than men, In all the field women are there. If we think about polite we remember ANNAI THERASA. No one men equal to Annai Therasa. Now our CM also a women. In old days also women are better managers for example JANSI RANI. Finally I would like to conclude women are having all the capabilities to manage everything and anything and men is not.|
|Nirupama Mohanty said: (Jul 30, 2013)|
|To be a manager one requires different skills like communication skills, conceptual skill, technical skill, human skill. And must pursue different qualities like monitoring, motivating, leadership etc. A person may have the managerial quality by birth or might have learnt and developed it- but the thing how he can manage things. As per the topic of discussion I personally feel that women are better managers.
The patience and perseverance that we find in women is rare to find in man.
Women today are no less than man they are the most powerful CEO'S, HR'S, MD.
As in above few of my friends have stated that the success story of men are more than women I would like to say that this is because of our fault, in past women were discarded from everything. Now when they got the opportunity they have proved it.
If a women is determined then she can achieve anything for which she is ready to faCe any hurdles.
Women if manages somthing then in proper and effective way it may be in home or office.
|Tasleema said: (Jul 29, 2013)|
|I think women and men are of the same place as they have got all equal rights and in this century women can face whatever a man can so I don't think so theres any difference the managerial skills depend on the experience they got the skill the talent they have got within them.
Everyone has their own inbuilt talent to become a manager it even depends on the passion they have it does not depend on the gender so I think manager are those who have passion, goal, leadership qualities in them nor between the gender its all about the skills they have within or which is been developed within. Thank you.
|Priti O Kapuriya said: (Jul 25, 2013)|
|Women are better managers because of the fact that they are the best economist.
It has been already proved by IIM's that women are the best managers or let me correct myself household women are best managers.
When it comes to a difficult situation women handle it very sensitively.
Examples to prove this point has an never ending list but even if we have to name a few- Chanda kocchar, Neelam Dhawan, Kiran M Shaw, Kiran Bedi, Chhavi Rajawat, sarpanch at village Soda in Rajasthan and Saloni Malhotra, Founder and CEO of first KPO in rural India - Desicrew Solutions.
At the end I would like to conclude- EAST or WEST home is the BEST, but only if a Women manages it!
|Anupam said: (Jul 16, 2013)|
|While considering from business point of view, I can say man's are good manager because of following points mentioned.
1. Manager do well only when they get authority and acceptability. From customer and people Man gets more acceptability.
2. Womans most of times brings emotions to workplaces which may harmful many times.
3. Man can manages stress very well and also most of time they do not let their hard feeling out (womans always do).
4. Biologically mans brain is 10 % bigger and heaving 4% more neurons which provides man multi task and multi thinking ability.
5. Managing company and managing house makes a great sense. If they manage.
6. Managing means well planned well manners. They why most of world violence is cause because of woman.
|Sothea Thoeun said: (Jul 13, 2013)|
|In my opinion men and women manager are not different. However the difference is about their qualities. We can not confirm that men manger is better that women manager and we can not say women manager is better than men manger as well. A good manager depend on their born talent, experience and required skills like.
- Technical skill.
- Human skills.
- Conceptual skills.
There are many example about good women manger and men manager in this world. Those good manager is from there born talent, experience and required skills and you all can be a good manager if you know what you lack of and then you fill up.
Please stop talking about men and women difference. The sound is like gender discrimination. :) The qualities of people is very important. How much they can inspire their people!
|Shivangi Rawat said: (Jun 18, 2013)|
|Managers are the individuals with managerial skills who lead a group of individuals directing, monitoring, taking corrective actions wherever necessary so as to achieve a common goal. And I personally believe that any individual with good managerial qualities can be an effective manager and when it comes to women they have been the best managers ever.
Not to forget Mrs. Indira Gandhi was India's first woman prime minister, Mrs Pratibha Devi Singh Patil was our recent president, Congress leader Mrs Sonia Gandhi, Razia Sultan, Rani laxmi bai during prehistoric times and the list goes on. Have proved that women are good managers.
In organizations too women play an important role though the number may be less when compared to men but that doesn't mean that women are not good managers. You all will be very glad to hear that women today are no less than men they are among the most powerful CEO's, executives, HR's, Managing Directors like Chanda kochhar of ICICI bank, Neelam Dhawan HP (india) , Kiran M Shaw of Biocon, and many more. These names completely speak of women being better managers.
For being a good manager one needs to have certain qualities like leadership, interpersonal skills, confidence. Women have been been managing home since olden times that is why they are even regarded as home makers. The patience and perseverance that you find in women is rare to find in men. Women have thus constantly proved that they are not only good at managing homes but also organizations.
In the nutshell I would like to conclude with a very apt adage which says "The Hand that rocks the cradle rules the world".
|Giri said: (May 27, 2013)|
|Managers have to manage everything with that what they have. They have to take care from small care to high professionals. And at the same time they have to consider each and every person's ideas like leaders.
We can see all those qualities in women. For this my mother is best example. She can manage all my home needs with the money that is given by my father. She has to take care all my family members and at the same she has to give respect to our thoughts and sometimes she decides which is suitable to us without any hesitation. So women have great capabilities to handle the difficult situations.
|Brijesh said: (Apr 19, 2013)|
|I think judge women about she has good skill to manage her home perfectly it's different think because there are no competition in her home for her place. No one can do her work in house and real corporate world there so many challenges who have to face it. And as far cooking concern man can cook well and mostly in cafes, hotels there man to cook a food.
Therefore I think women are good manager because she is good as house wife it's not right. If every success man behind women then let me say there are so many unsuccess man whom also has women. Good manager is good because he/she has good skill to compete the world it's doesn't matter women or man.
|Hitixa said: (Apr 15, 2013)|
|It's very confusing to decide about better management of men vs women because in this competitive world day by day, women are becoming more & more confident & capable to handle any situation, any status, any level, any tasks, any challenges.
On the other hand, we can't forget men. They have also proved their best management-skills in the various fields.
So friends, we should try to understand this thing. We should start thinking about this little difference between men's & women's management methods.
No one is "Mr/Mrs Perfectionist" even in a single field.
Thank you for reading my opinion.
|Sachin said: (Feb 28, 2013)|
Today's very critical topic of Discussion, As per my point of view is Men's are good managers compare to women's. I know women's having patience, clam and good decision making skills. Women makes good Manager and leaders etc, because women's have a power to make a king. I would like to say that Women's are kingmaker.
|Aparajita Pandey said: (Feb 9, 2013)|
|Well I think man and woman both are made by same human anatomy, both have 24 hrs in a day, so if you want to judge a person that whether he/she is a good manager or not judge him/her on the basis of skills, communication skill, education, not on the basis of gender.
Woman can be a better manager than a man, man can be a better manager than woman, depends on the qualities.
|Hitesh Ahuja said: (Jan 30, 2013)|
|Friends in my opinion there is not different between man and woman because both are made by god. So for a good manager requires education, communication skill, management skill, and power to take decision in citical situation and these all quality he/she who had is a good manager. So a woman should be a good manager in my view.|
Do Women make Good Managers?
Email : (optional)
» Your comments will be displayed only after manual approval.